After each season NEAFL officials name a Team of the Year consisting of the best performing players during the home-and-away rounds.

From 2011-2013 the Northern and Eastern Conferences had separate teams before the NEAFL merged the two conferences into a single league in 2014. 

2019 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Brodie Murdoch (Southport) Mathew Eagles (Brisbane) Tom Highmore (Canberra)

HB: Angus Baker (Canberra) Gavin Grose (Aspley) Ryley Stoddart (Sydney)

C: Nick Shipley (GIANTS) Matthew Payne (Aspley) Alex Smout (Canberra)

HF: James Rose (Sydney) Clay Cameron (Redland) Ryan Bastinac (Brisbane)

F: Ben Keays (Brisbane) Matt Hammelmann (Redland) Mitch Hardie (Canberra)

Foll: Tom Nicholls (Gold Coast) Abraham Ankers (NT Thunder) Andrew Boston (Southport)

Interchange: Jake Bartholomaeus (Sydney Uni) Adam Gulden (Sydney Uni) Corey Lyons (Brisbane) Keidean Coleman (Brisbane) Craig Malone (Redland)

Coach: Mitch Hahn (Brisbane)
Captain: Abraham Ankers (NT Thunder)

2018 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Ryan Hebron (Sydney University) Adrian Williams (Redland) Colin O’Riordan (Sydney)

HB: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) Liam Dawson (Brisbane) Adam Gulden (Sydney University)

C: Josh Clayton (Southport) Matthew Payne (Aspley) Ben Warren (Aspley)

HF: Mitch Hardie (Canberra) Jackson Paine (Redland) Michael Manteit (Southport)

F: Tom Wilkinson (Southport) Matt Hammelmann (Redland) Tom Young (Sydney University)

Foll: Darcy Cameron (Sydney) Andrew Swallow (Aspley) Mitch Maguire (Canberra)

Inter: Jake Spencer (Aspley) Abraham Ankers (NT Thunder) Jacob Dawson (Gold Coast) Aidan Bonar (GIANTS) Craig Bird (Sydney University)

Coach: Stephen Daniel (Southport)

Captain: Matthew Payne (Aspley)

2017 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Ryan Hebron (Sydney University) Adrian Williams (Redland) Darcy Baron-Hay (Sydney University)

HB: Jeremy Laidler (Sydney) Gavin Grose (Aspley) Ryan Davis (Gold Coast)

W: Jordan Harper (Canberra) Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) Brandon Jack (Sydney)

HF: Jordan Dawson (Sydney) Jono Freeman (Brisbane) Clay Cameron (Redland)

F: Darcy Macpherson (Gold Coast) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Jackson Paine (Redland)

Foll: Dawson Simpson (GIANTS) Jordan Keras (Southport) Mitch Hallahan (Gold Coast)

Inter: Oscar McInerney (Brisbane) Zac O’Brien (Sydney University) Matt Payne (Aspley) Sam Murray (Sydney) Adam Sambono (NT Thunder)

Coach: Tom Morrison (Sydney University)

Captain: Gavin Grose (Aspley)

2016 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Jackson Allen (Aspley) Matthew Sully (Southport) William Sierakowski (Sydney University)

HB: Nic Newman (Sydney) Harrison Himmelberg (Giants) Raphael Clarke (NT Thunder)

C: Brandon Jack (Sydney) Matthew Payne (Aspley) Jordan Foote (Sydney)

HF: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) Jacob Derickx (Sydney University) Andrew Boston (Southport)

F: James Nelis (Aspley) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Sam Reid (Giants)

Foll: Fraser Thurlow (Southport) Jordan Harper (Canberra) Tom Young (Sydney University)

Inter: Colin O’Riordan (Sydney) Matthew Rawlinson (Sydney University) Blake Grewar (Redland) James Ives (Aspley) Toby Nankervis (Sydney)

Coach: Rhyce Shaw (Sydney)

Captain: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder)

2015 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Harry Marsh (Sydney Swans) Justin Beugelaar (NT Thunder) Lewis Stevenson (Sydney University)

HB: Josh Wagner (Aspley) Gavin Grose (Aspley) Curtly Hampton (UWS Giants)

C: Richard Tambling (NT Thunder) Matt Payne (Aspley) Josh Smith (Redland)

HF: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) (c) Jack Anthony (Southport) Jed Lamb (UWS Giants)

F: Eddie Sansbury (Aspley) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Matt Rawlinson (Sydney University)

Foll: Ben Dowdell (Eastlake) Tom Young (Sydney University) Zac O’Brien (Brisbane)

Inter: Matt Uebergang (Redland) Jake Barrett (UWS Giants) George Hewett (Sydney) Nick Salter (Ainslie) Tyrone Downie (Gold Coast)

Coach: Brett Hand (UWS Giants)

Captain: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder)

2014 NEAFL TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Matthew O’Dwyer (Sydney Uni) Timothy Barton (Sydney Uni) Shane Biggs (Sydney)

HB: Kade Klemke (Queanbeyan) Wayde Mills (Southport) Will Sierakowski (Sydney Uni)

C: Zachery O’Brien (Brisbane) Matthew Payne (Aspley) Blake Grewer (Redland)

HF: Chris Dunne (NT Thunder) Nick Salter (Ainslie) Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder)

F: Eddie Sansbury (Aspley) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Cleve Hughes (Redland)

Foll: Paul Hunter (Redland) Aaron Vandenberg (Ainslie) Mark Whiley (GWS Giants)

Inter: Daniel Robinson (Sydney) Jason Burge (Southport) Jordan Harper (Belconnen) Matt Buntine (GWS Giants)

Captain: Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder)

Coach: Xavier Clarke (NT Thunder)

2013 NEAFL NORTHERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Brad Howard (Redland) Michael Hutchinson (Aspley) Wayde Mills (Southport)

HB: Daniel Wise (Southport) Scott Clarke (Morningside) Daniel Dzufer (Redland)

C: Cheynee Stiller (Aspley) Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) Patrick Karnezis (Brisbane)

HF: Chris Dunne (NT Thunder) Steven Gaertner (Redland) Josh Baxter (Southport)

F: Jason Burge (Southport) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Jack Martin (Gold Coast)

Foll: Fraser Thurlow (Labrador) Jack Crisp (Brisbane) Haydn Kiel (Southport)

Inter: Ryan Matthews (Aspley) Adam Eckermann (Mt Gravatt) Mitch Brewer (Broadbeach) Paul Shelton (Morningside)

2013 NEAFL EASTERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Shane Biggs (Sydney) John Van Meurs (Eastlake) Cameron Campbell (Belconnen)

HB: Kade Klemke (Queanbeyan) Tim Barton (Sydney Uni) Sam Darley (GWS Giants)

C: Aaron Vandenberg (Ainslie)  Anthony Miles (GWS Giants) Jake Lloyd (Sydney)

HF: Ash Harris (Ainslie) Andrew Dess (Belconnen) Daniel Robinson (Sydney)

F: Tim Barrett (Sydney Uni) Josh Bennett (Ainslie) Matthew Lokan (Belconne

Foll: Tom Downie (GWS Giants) James Bennett (Belconnen) Kaine Stevens (Queanbeyan)

Inter: Brent Macleod (Tuggeranong) Nick Heyne (Ainslie) Trent Stubbs (Sydney Hills Eagles) Matthew Porter (Belconnen).

2012 NEAFL NORTHERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Danny Wise (Southport) Jason Roe (NT Thunder) Steve Wrigley (Brisbane)

HB: Todd Grayson (Labrador) Wayde Mills (Southport) Adam Oxley (Redland)

C: James Hawksley (Brisbane) Jake Dignan (NT Thunder) Cheynee Stiller (Brisbane)

HF: Matthew Payne (Aspley) Scott Clouston (Redland) Josh Baxter (Southport)

F: Gavin Grose (MtG) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Sam Faure (Morningside)

R: Dylan Reid (Aspley) Andrew McQualter (Gold Coast) Jason Burge (Southport)

Inter: Ryan Davey (Labrador) Brad Rees (Redland) Phil Carse (Redland) Matt Rosier (NT Thunder) Ryan Pantic (Broadbeach).

2012 NEAFL EASTERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Dale Walker (Ainslie) Roy Jaques (Queanbeyan) Kade Klemke (Queanbeyan)

HB: Aaron Bruce (Eastlake) Josh Bruce (GWS Giants) Marcus Crook (Ainslie)

C: Toby Conroy (Queanbeyan) Jarred Moore (Sydney) Josh Moody (Eastlake)

HF: Kaine Stevens (Queanbeyan) Jamie Vlatko (Sydney Hills Eagles) Nicholas Paine (Ainslie)

F: Mitch Morton (Sydney) James Kavanagh (Queanbeyan) Shane Harris (Belconnen)

Foll: Jesse White (Sydney) William Griggs (Queanbeyan) Tom Ayton (Eastlake)

Inter: Alexander Lee (Sydney Uni) Marc Dragicevic (Tuggeranong) Ryan Brabazon (Eastlake) Ryan Houlihan (Sydney Hills Eagles) Simon Horner (Ainslie) Matthew Porter (Belconnen)

2011 NEAFL NORTHERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Nathan Kinch (Morningside) Gavin Grose (Mt Gravatt) Caleb Brown (Morningside)

HB: Robbie Copeland (Aspley) Shaun Tapp (NT Thunder) Steve Wrigley (Labrador)

C: Kallen Geary (Broadbeach) Cameron Ilett (NT Thunder) Ryan Davey (Labrador)

HF: Albert Proud (Mt Gravatt) Kent Abey (Morningside) Micah Buchanan (Aspley)

F: Ross Tungatalum (NT Thunder) Darren Ewing (NT Thunder) Chris Smith (Mt Gravatt)

Foll: Kenrick Tyrrell (NT Thunder) Matthew Payne (Southport) Dayne Zorko (Broadbeach)

Inter: Paul Shelton (Morningside) Matt Jones (Labrador) Amon Buchanan (Brisbane Lions) Jacob Gilbee (Gold Coast Suns) Scott Clouston (Redland).

2011 NEAFL EASTERN CONFERENCE TEAM OF THE YEAR

B: Rob Tuohey (Ainslie) Jack Hombsch (GWS Giants) Mitch Frail (Eastlake)

HB: David Smith (Tuggeranong) Simon Curtis (Belconnen) Dale Walker (Ainslie)

C: Marcus Crook (Ainslie) Robert Shirley (Ainslie) Aaron Wiles (Eastlake)

HF: Aaron Bruce (Eastlake) Ben Hughes (Ainslie) Nathan Gordon (Sydney)

F: James Kavanagh (Queanbeyan) Trent Dennis-Lane (Sydney) Nick Paine (Ainslie)

Foll: Jonathon Giles (GWS Giants) Dylan Shiel (GWS Giants) Ben Cleaver (Tuggeranong)

Inter: Chad Gibson (Eastlake) Jeremy Cameron (GWS Giants) Todd Dickinson (Queanbeyan) Kane Murphy (Sydney)